Alas, we have finally finished compiling our 2011 sunscreen recommendations. As you will notice, our list is a rather short one since we are only willing to recommend sunscreens that we have used or would use on our own children. Our recommendations are based on the following factors:
- The Environmental Working Group’s (EWG) ratings and ingredient information;
- Amazon ratings and reviews;
- Consumer Reports (July 2011) information (includes feedback on 2 of our sunscreen picks);
- Our own experience with the products and/or interaction with the Companies themselves;
- This might come as a shocker, but we also tend to lean towards sunscreens with organic ingredients. ;)
With the exception of one sunscreen that contains both zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, we are only recommending sunscreens that use zinc oxide as the active ingredient, since zinc oxide is the only mineral that offers broad spectrum protection against UVA and UVB rays and because most of the research we read found that even coated titanium dioxide is inferior to uncoated zinc oxide. If this sounds like gibberish to you and you’d like to read more about the differences between the minerals zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, we laid out everything you need to know about sunscreen in our recent article titled “How Safe is Your Sunscreen? The ABC’s of Sunscreens…”
Unfortunately we were not able to research every highly-rated zinc oxide sunscreen. If you use one that you’re passionate about, please let us know. If we don’t go broke trying out all of these sunscreens, then we’ll happily try out any new sunscreen provided that it passes the initial PureBebe screening.
I would also like to note that in the past we have raved about California Baby products. We have not included them in our list below for three reasons. First, they use titanium dioxide as the active ingredient in their sunscreens, and as mentioned above, we are only recommending sunscreens with zinc oxide. Secondly, they did not respond to my email questions, and we have since learned that they have not responded to other bloggers’ inquiries as well. Thirdly, because they did not respond to my inquiry, I do not know whether their titanium dioxide is, in fact, safe (i.e. coated/uncoated and nano/non-nano). As a loyal buyer and an evangelist of their products for 3.5 years, I find their unresponsiveness completely unprofessional and unacceptable.
Without further ado, below are our top picks for 2011:
Loving Naturals Sunscreen, SPF 30+
Active Ingredient: Uncoated, non-nano zinc oxide (24.8%)
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: 3.5 stars, 299 customer reviews
Best Price We’ve Found: $9.99 for 2.7 oz, $17.00 for 5 oz on Amazon.com
Positives: Jasmine says “I love that this mineral-based sunscreen has such an easy-to-read ingredients list of natural and organic ingredients, all of which are described on the company’s website along with their purpose. It has a mild, nutty scent and a smooth, lotion-like consistency for a mineral-based sunscreen that makes it really easy to apply. And while it goes on white, it rubs in easily.”
Negatives: Jasmine says “Compared to some other mineral-based sunscreens I’ve used, this one requires reapplication more frequently. This sunscreen contains nut and seed oils, so do not use if your child has nut or seed allergies.”
Badger Baby Sunscreen SPF 30+
Active Ingredient: Uncoated, non-nano zinc oxide (18.75%). Note: earlier versions of this product contained nano zinc oxide, so make sure that you buy the bottle that says “non-nano” on the label.
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: 3.5 stars, 8 reviews
Best Price We’ve Found: $14.00 for 2.9 oz on Amazon.com
Positives: Heather says “This one is on my list of sunscreens to try. I recently bought the lavender-scented Badger sunscreen when I saw it available at my local supermarket (they don’t have the unscented version), only to read on the EWG’s website that lavender (as well as many scents added to lotions) is a known endocrine disruptor. Given the list of ingredients on the Baby sunscreen, and the countless people who have raved about this Badger sunscreen (friends as well as online reviews), I can’t wait to try this one on my kids. As a sidenote, I also love how open this company is about their products, the ingredients, and why they chose specific ingredients over others. Very, very refreshing!”
Consumer Report’s July 2011 edition rated Badger SPF 30 as #6 for all sunscreens in the SPF30 market.
Negatives: Heather says, “Not all Badger products have the same safety ratings from the EWG. Their Anti-Bug Sunscreen is rated a 3 by the EWG, so make sure to check EWG’s site if you’d prefer to buy a different Badger product.”
Consumer Reports noted that Badger stains clothing, so be careful when applying.
Poofy Supernaturals Sunscreen SPF 30
Active Ingredient: Uncoated, non-nano zinc oxide (22.5%). A company representative said that their zinc oxide is 325 nm in size.
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: Not listed/Not rated
Best Price We’ve Found: $11.99 for 2.0 oz at Poofy Organics.com
Positives: Although we haven’t yet tried this one, the list of all-natural ingredients pleasantly surprised me: Organic Jojoba Oil, Organic Unrefined Shea Butter, Organic Beeswax, Organic Virgin Coconut Oil, Organic Camellia Oil, Organic Cocoa Butter, Zinc Oxide, Organic Rosemary Extract, Organic Eucalyptus Essential Oil, Natural Vitmain E.
Negatives: This sunscreen does have coconut oil, which some kids could be allergic to.
Soleo Organics All Natural Sunscreen SPF 30+
Active Ingredient: Zinc Oxide (22.3%)
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: 4 stars, 42 customer reviews
Best Price We’ve Found: $20.99 for 2.8 oz. on Amazon.com
Positives: This one is on our list to try. Many of the reviews mentioned that this one is really hard to find because it’s such a great product.
In Consumer Reports July 2011 edition, they rated Soleo as #5 for all SPF 30 sunscreens.
Negatives: It is a little pricey.
Also, Consumer Reports 7/2011 edition noted that Soleo fared better than Badger for protecting against UVB rays after use in the water, and that it did stain clothing, but less so than Badger.
Coola MineralBaby Moisturizer Suncare, Unscented, SPF 45
Active Ingredient: Titanium Dioxide (10%), Zinc Oxide (7%)
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: 4 stars, 2 customer reviews
Best Price We’ve Found: $34 for 3 oz. on Amazon.com
Positives: Jasmine says, “Another mineral-based sunscreen with a great list of natural and organic ingredients. It has no scent, and it provides excellent sun protection. My family and I wore it four days straight in the blazing sun of Orlando – we only applied once each morning and stayed burn-free.”
Negatives: Jasmine says, “Expensive! I only purchased this because it met the SPF requirements for FSA reimbursement, and I had dollars to burn. This sunscreen takes some muscle to get out of the tube. It is quite thick, and it goes on quite greasy as well which likely means excellent water resistance. It’d be a good sunscreen for beach and water activities. It’s incredibly difficult to wash off your hands after applying, and the same goes for your clothes so be careful.”
TruKid Sunny Days SPORT Water Resistant Sunscreen SPF 30+, Unscented
Active Ingredient: Non-nano zinc oxide (24.8%)
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: Not Rated
Best Price We’ve Found: $18.99 for a 3.5 oz tube on Amazon.com
Positives: Heather says “This sunscreen has a great list of natural ingredients.”
Negatives: Heather says “I have listed this sunscreen lotion last since the list of ingredients on their website does not match up with the EWG’s list of ingredients. I am assuming that the company’s website and ingredients are the most up-to-date. I have contacted the company to inquire about whether they are in fact using PHENOXYETHANOL in this sunscreen (as stated on the EWG’s site), which can cause organ system toxicity. I will update this post when I hear back from them. But for now, if you do not see PHENOXYETHANOL on the bottle’s list of ingredients, then they have changed the ingredients and are not longer using it. As we have mentioned before with other sunscreen makers, not all of TruKid’s sunscreens have safe ingredients. So if you are interested in buying a TruKid product other than the SPORT sunscreen, please check the EWG’s site for ingredients ratings.
Updated, 7/12/2011 (Email response from TruKid):
“None of our sunscreens use PHENOXYETHANOL. We reformulated this year and replaced it with polyminopropyl biguanide. We found this to be better, safer sunscreen for our products. As we find better ingredient alternatives that are stable, we reformulate as soon as we are able. Our website should match EWG/our lables, if we have inadvertently not matched them it is generally an oversight that we will correct as we hear of it.”
Also, they used to make a highly rated SPORTS stick that I was going to recommend. But, I couldn’t find it for sale on their website or Amazon. Frustrating! They do make a non-SPORT stick that IS readily available on Amazon and their website, and it is rated a “2″ on the EWG website, probably because it contains ALUMINUM STEARATE (rated a ’4′ on the EWG’s list of ingredients). According to the EWG’s list of ingredients for this product, ALUMINUM STEARATE can cause “Developmental/reproductive toxicity, Neurotoxicity, Multiple, additive exposure sources.” For this reason, we are only recommending their SPORT sunscreen lotion.”
Updated, 7/12/2011 (Email response from TruKid):
This product Sunny Days SPORT SPF35 does not have Aluminum Sterate in it (non of our sticks have it) (we made a mistake when entering the ingredients and we immediately asked for help in revising from EWG and they have yet to fix it. (months ago) Again EWG is trying hard to create a site that is accurate and informative. Unfortunately their website tools are clunky and are unchangeable unless they change it for you.
Thank you, TruKid, for getting back to us so promptly!
Loving Naturals Sunscreen Stick, SPF 30+

Active Ingredient: Non-nano zinc oxide (24.8%)
EWG Skin Deep Rating: 1
Amazon Rating: 4 stars, 14 customer reviews
Best Price We’ve Found: $9.99 for a .84 oz tube on Amazon.com, Lovingnaturals.com
Positives: Jasmine says “Just like the sunscreen lotion, I love the stick’s ingredients listed on the company’s website. This stick has a non-greasy formula that stays put. In fact, it’s one of the least greasy formulas that I’ve come across.”
Negatives: Jasmine says, “It doesn’t rub on as smoothly as I would like, sort of pasty, and it leaves a slight, white residue. The residue is to be expected, though, from a zinc oxide sunscreen, and it can be mostly rubbed in.
Loving Naturals has just released the Adorable Baby Sunscreen Stick that claims to go on clear with an improved consistency, using a clear uncoated non-nano zinc oxide. It has achieved the same Skin Deep Rating as its white counterpart, so you can bet we’ll be trying this one out in the near future.”
This research has taken us FOUR weeks to conduct, vet and formulate. We do this for free, in our “spare” (haha) time, while we both have other paying jobs and, of course our precious children to take care of. Please visit our Facebook page (link in top right corner of this page) and “Like” us. And please tell your friends about us!